Key Lime Pie Cheesecake Piña Colada Recipe

There’s nothing quite like the bright, citrusy burst of key lime pie, the creamy richness of cheesecake, and the tropical sweetness of a piña colada—so why not combine all three? This Key Lime Pie Cheesecake Piña Colada is a luscious, dreamy cocktail that brings the best of dessert and island vibes into one irresistible drink.

this Recipe

I first crafted this cocktail on a summer getaway, inspired by a craving for something both indulgent and refreshing. The result? A silky, tangy, coconut-kissed frozen drink that has become my go-to for poolside lounging and dinner parties alike.

Cool, creamy, and bursting with flavor, this tropical twist on a classic cocktail is sure to be a new favorite.

Why You'll Love This Key Lime Pie Cheesecake Piña Colada

Get ready to sip on pure vacation bliss! This cocktail is a must-try for so many reasons.

First, it’s an incredible fusion of flavors. Imagine the zesty brightness of key lime pie, the rich tang of cheesecake, and the smooth coconut-rum sweetness of a classic piña colada—all blended into one decadent, drinkable dessert.

It’s also amazingly easy to make. Just toss everything into a blender, and in minutes, you have a creamy, frosty cocktail that tastes like a bartender-crafted masterpiece.

For those who love a beautifully garnished drink, this one is a showstopper. Topped with whipped cream, a graham cracker rim, and a slice of fresh lime, it looks as amazing as it tastes.

Finally, it’s perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re hosting a summer BBQ, relaxing by the pool, or simply craving a tropical escape, this drink delivers sunshine in every sip.

Ingredients Notes

The magic of this Key Lime Pie Cheesecake Piña Colada lies in its carefully chosen ingredients, each one playing a role in creating the perfect creamy, citrusy, and tropical balance.

Key lime juice is the star of this drink. It provides the bright, tart punch that balances the sweetness of the other ingredients. Freshly squeezed key limes work best, but bottled key lime juice is a convenient and equally delicious option.

Cream cheese gives the cocktail its signature cheesecake richness. When blended with the other ingredients, it creates an ultra-creamy texture that sets this piña colada apart.

Coconut cream is what makes a piña colada truly indulgent. Unlike coconut milk, it has a higher fat content, making the drink velvety smooth while enhancing its tropical essence.

White rum adds just the right amount of warmth, complementing the sweetness without overpowering the lime and coconut flavors. If you prefer a stronger kick, try using coconut or vanilla-flavored rum for an extra layer of depth.

For that authentic graham cracker crust flavor, crushed graham crackers are used to rim the glass. It’s the perfect finishing touch, mimicking the beloved crust of a key lime pie.

A high-powered blender is essential for achieving the perfectly smooth, frozen consistency that makes this cocktail irresistibly creamy.

How To Make This Key Lime Pie Cheesecake Piña Colada

Creating this deliciously indulgent cocktail is as simple as blending up a slice of tropical paradise.

Start by preparing your garnished glasses. Crush a few graham crackers into fine crumbs and pour them onto a small plate. Rim your glasses with a bit of honey or lime juice, then dip them into the crumbs for a pie-like finish.

Next, it’s time to blend. In a high-speed blender, combine ice, key lime juice, cream cheese, coconut cream, white rum, and a touch of simple syrup or sweetened condensed milk for extra creaminess. Blend until smooth and creamy, ensuring that the cream cheese fully incorporates into the mixture.

Once blended, taste the mixture and adjust as needed. If you love extra tartness, squeeze in more key lime juice. For a sweeter, dessert-like experience, add a drizzle of condensed milk.

Pour the mixture into your prepared glasses, filling them to the top with the creamy, frosty goodness.

For the final touch, top with whipped cream, a sprinkle of graham cracker crumbs, and a fresh lime wedge. If you want to go all out, a toasted coconut rim or a drizzle of caramel makes this drink even more decadent.

This entire process takes just five minutes, making it the perfect quick and easy cocktail for any occasion.

Storage Options

While this cocktail is best enjoyed fresh, you can make a batch in advance and store it in the freezer for later.

For short-term storage, pour the blended mixture into a sealed container and keep it in the freezer for up to one hour. Stir well before serving, or blend again with a splash of rum or coconut milk to restore its smooth consistency.

If you have leftovers, freeze them in an ice cube tray. Later, you can blend the frozen cubes with a bit of coconut milk to quickly recreate the creamy texture without watering it down.

Variations and Substitutions

This recipe is wonderfully versatile, allowing you to customize it to your taste or dietary needs.

For a non-alcoholic version, simply skip the rum and replace it with coconut water or a splash of pineapple juice. You’ll still get that creamy, tropical flavor without the alcohol.

If you want a lighter version, use Greek yogurt instead of cream cheese. It will still provide a creamy texture while adding a slight tang and extra protein.

Love coconut? Try using coconut rum instead of white rum, or add a handful of toasted coconut flakes into the blender for an extra layer of flavor.

For a fruitier twist, blend in a handful of frozen pineapple or mango. This adds a natural sweetness and enhances the tropical vibe of the drink.

Experimenting with flavors is half the fun! Whether you tweak the sweetness, tartness, or richness, this cocktail is easy to customize to your liking.

Print